Why I Decided Not to Continue With Weight Loss Surgery Through the Tier 3/4 Pathway

For a while, I genuinely thought weight loss surgery might be part of my future.

When I joined the Tier 3 and Tier 4 weight management pathway, I went into it with an open mind. I wasn’t desperate to have weight loss surgery, but I wasn’t ruling it out either. After years of struggling with my weight, losing around 10 stone, regaining some of it and finding myself wondering what the next step should be, it felt sensible to explore all the options available.

Over the months that followed, I attended appointments, listened to advice and spent a lot of time thinking about what I wanted for my future. The more I learned, the more I realised this wasn’t just a decision about weight loss. It was a decision about my lifestyle, my relationship with food and how I wanted to approach my health in the years ahead. In the end, I decided not to continue with the pathway.

That doesn’t mean I think weight loss surgery is wrong. Far from it. I know many people whose lives have been transformed by bariatric surgery and I have huge respect for anyone who chooses that route. This article isn’t about convincing anyone else what they should do.

It’s simply an honest account of why I decided surgery wasn’t the right option for me at that point in my life, the concerns I had and why I wanted to explore other approaches first.

Why I Started the Tier 3 and Tier 4 Pathway

I was referred to the Tier 3 and 4 pathway by my GP. This was following an appointment with my sleep apnea consultant, whom I had spoken to about how I was trying to lose weight, and I knew that could help with the sleep apnea. He asked my GP to help me with my weight in his clinic letter. The next thing I knew I had been referred. No discussion, no understanding of what the different NHS tiers meant for weight loss or where he was referring me to, just a referral to the Derby Hospital bariatric team.

When I went to the initial appointment with the team at Derby, I was shocked to find they only offer a pathway to surgery; there is nothing else available, and if you do not want surgery, you are discharged. I stayed in the system, agreeing in principle to surgery, but wanting to think about it more. That said, they said the pathway takes years before you get a surgery date: one year of making lifestyle and dietary changes to show your commitment to the changes required after surgery, and only then would you be considered for listing, with another wait for a weight loss surgery date.

I’d struggled with my weight for years and, whilst I had previously lost over 10 stone, I knew first-hand that maintaining weight loss could be just as challenging as losing it in the first place. I wasn’t joining the pathway because I had already decided I wanted surgery. If anything, I joined to understand all the available options and make an informed decision.

At that stage, I was trying to keep an open mind. Weight-loss surgery clearly helps many people, and I wasn’t prepared to dismiss it without fully understanding what it involved. I attended appointments, followed the diet changes they suggested, listened carefully, and asked lots of questions, hoping that somewhere along the way I’d get a clear sense of whether it was right for me.

Why Weight Loss Surgery Never Quite Felt Right for Me

The easiest way I can explain it is that surgery always felt like something I might consider in the future, rather than something I was ready for right now. Every time I thought about it, I kept coming back to the same feeling: I wasn’t finished exploring other options.

Perhaps that was because I’d lost a significant amount of weight before without weight loss surgery. Whilst I hadn’t maintained all of that loss, knowing I had achieved it once made me feel that I still had avenues I wanted to explore before considering a life-changing operation.

At the time, medications such as Wegovy were becoming more widely available, and I was curious about whether they could help. I also wanted to focus on improving my eating habits, increasing my activity levels, and better understanding my own relationship with food.

Deep down, I don’t think I was looking at weight loss surgery and thinking, “This is the answer.” I was looking at it and wondering whether I was ready for it. The answer was always the same. Not yet.

The Lifestyle Changes Felt Bigger Than weight loss surgery

One thing that really surprised me was how little I worried about the operation itself. Instead, I found myself thinking about life afterwards. The diet plan to follow initially was absolutely fine. I was encouraged to eat more protein, drink more water, etc., but they also discussed what you can and can’t eat after surgery.

They also advised you to join a Facebook group for patients, past and present, of the weight loss surgery team at Derby, to understand other people’s experiences and how surgery had changed them.

I would be driving somewhere or sitting watching television, and my mind would drift to everyday situations. Family meals. Holidays. Christmas dinner. Going out for lunch with friends. Stopping for coffee and cake on a day out. Food has always been about more than simply eating for me. It’s tied up with celebrations, memories, socialising and spending time with people I care about.

The more I learned about life after weight loss surgery, the more I realised just how much would change. I read stories of people asking how soon they would be moving off purees; these people were 3 weeks post-operation. I couldn’t imagine 3 weeks of purees! Other people were talking about side effects and issues after surgery etc. For every one of these stories, I thought, I couldn’t cope with that; it sounds horrible!

I know many people adapt brilliantly and go on to have fantastic lives after weight loss surgery, but I couldn’t ignore the fact that it felt huge to me. The idea of permanently changing my relationship with food felt far more significant than the operation itself.

And yes, I will admit that I even found myself thinking about things like bottomless brunches! It sounds ridiculous when you’re discussing a serious health decision, but I think those little thoughts mattered because they reflected how much I was thinking about the reality of everyday life rather than simply the weight loss.

The Things I Worried About Most

If I’m honest, there wasn’t one big reason I decided not to continue. It was lots of little things.

The puree stage after weight loss surgery genuinely didn’t appeal to me at all. I know it’s temporary, and I know people get through it successfully every day, but every time I read about it, I would find myself thinking how much I would hate it.

I also worried about recovery. Because I have allergies to most stronger painkillers, I couldn’t help wondering whether managing pain after surgery might be more difficult for me than it is for some people.

Neither of those things alone would have stopped me from having surgery. What mattered more was that they all added to a growing feeling that I wasn’t comfortable taking that step yet.

The Moment I Realised My Decision

Looking back, I don’t think there was one dramatic moment when I decided not to continue. Instead, there was a gradual realisation that whenever I thought about weight loss surgery, I felt reluctant. Not frightened. Not completely against it. Just reluctant.

On the other hand, whenever I thought about trying other options first, I felt hopeful. I wanted to see whether medication could help. I wanted to work on my eating habits. I wanted to increase my activity levels. Most importantly, I wanted to know I had explored every avenue before making a decision that would permanently change my life.

Eventually, I realised that feeling was probably telling me everything I needed to know. I emailed the Bariatric team at Derby (they prefer this contact method as they are hard to get hold of by phone) and said I had decided I didn’t want weight loss surgery.

What happened next surprised me. I didn’t get an email back, I didn’t have a phone call or a letter. Nothing! The GP only knows I stopped this pathway because I told them. The Bariatric team simply discharged me without so much as a letter or contact to confirm this was what I was sure about, or even just to tell my GP. I was really surprised by this.

Why I’m Happy With My Decision

Walking away from the pathway didn’t feel like giving up. If anything, it felt like taking ownership of my own health journey. Weight loss surgery is an incredible option for many people and I have nothing but respect for those who choose it. I’ve seen the difference it can make and I know it changes lives.

For me, though, it wasn’t the right step at that point in my life. Maybe that will change one day. Maybe it won’t. But when I made the decision to step away from the pathway, I felt relief rather than regret, and I think that probably tells me I made the right choice.

This was the beginning of February this year, so four months ago. Maybe a letter will appear at some point, maybe not, but in the last 4 months, I haven’t doubted that decision, not once, so it is obviously right for me. Weight loss surgery is an amazing tool for some people but at the moment it just isn’t for me.

Have you considered weight loss surgery? Maybe you have had it and think I made the wrong decision? Let me know in the comments below.

Pin this post for later

If you found this helpful please share!